No, I am not about to go traipsing around town. Today, is a Spanish national holiday, and Madrid looks like they rolled up the sidewalks for the day. The reason I am here at all, two days ahead of the Boccherini conference that starts tomorrow, is that I wanted to be sure to be here. Traveling on a free ticket, space available basis, is always risky. Coming to think of it, the cost of two nights in this fancy hotel would probably equal the price of a full fair ticket, but then, I now have a chance of getting over the cursed jet-lag before I have to read this lecture the day after tomorrow....
Anyway, my friend Luis gave me as a present the complete run of all issues of the Spanish guitar magazine called Roseta. I knew about this magazine, tried to get a subscription to it, hoped to be able to send them review copies of my editions, but so far, all my attempts failed. They never answered my inquiries, or, most probably, I wrote to the wrong person. Now that I have all the issues, 5 of them so far, I must say that I am very impressed. Technically speaking, this is one of the best executed guitar publication. Excellent graphics, first class professional typography, and high level editorial control. As for the contents: my brief perusal of some of the articles published, particularly those where my name is mentioned, showed me that I am not as clever as I thought I was. Some ideas that I expressed in recent writing and in lectures, were already discussed by others, without my knowledge of them, and probably without their knowledge of me. Then there is also the case of people writing on subjects on which I published extensive material, without even a footnote referring to my 25 year old writings on the same subject (the article on guitar notation for example). Not the first time this happened, and I am sure not the last time either. Nevertheless, this type of missing credits always gets my goat...
Then there is the question of reviews of my editions. Since I was never able to establish contact with this magazine, I never sent them any review copies. That has not prevented them from publishing extensive reviews of some of my editions, particularly those with some historical reference, i.e., de Fossa, Regondi etc. Reading such reviews, it is always interesting to read what other people think of my work, and the very fact that they consider it at all, is always welcome news. Then there is the case of their critical remarks of my work. When a Spanish reviewer catches my misprint of a Spanish name, then it is of course a good thing, and his hopes that the mistake will be corrected in the next printing is of course a good thing as well, but I am afraid that some of these editions will never see a reprint. So it goes.
The difficulty I have is with critical comments that are completely off the wall, exhibiting the writer's total ignorance regarding the mechanics of music publication. In the past, when a magazine was unable to control such deleterious comments on the part of their reviewers, Classical Guitar magazine for example, I demonstratively stopped sending them review copies, and demonstratively they retaliated by stopping to send me their magazine for free, as they did from their very first issue in 1982. But in this case, my actions are limited. Roseta never sent me anything, and I never sent them anything either. So now I have to consider what would be the correct forum in which to express my displeasure with such incompetence. I will have to cogitate about this, and perhaps discuss the matter with some of my Spanish colleagues.